QOD

Filed in National by on June 15, 2008

If you were stranded on an island, what 5 music albums would you have to have?

About the Author ()

hiding in the open

Comments (71)

Trackback URL | Comments RSS Feed

  1. Counting Crows, Recovering the Satelites
    Pink Floyd, Wish You were Here
    Our Lady Peace, Happiness is not a fish you can catch
    Chevelle, Wonder What’s next
    Silversun Pickups Carnavas

  2. Stella Bluez says:

    U2- Achtung Baby
    Peter Gabriel- So
    Gomez- In Our Gun
    Iron & Wine- Shepard’s Dog
    Any live Pearl Jam!!

    of course in 10 minutes I’m going to think of 3 more…..soooo many…..

  3. American Beauty, Grateful Dead
    Fear of Music, Talking Heads
    Briefcase Full of Blues, Blues Brothers
    The Fugs First Album, The Fugs
    The Times They Are A-Changin’, Bob Dylan

  4. liberalgeek says:

    Cream – Disraeli Gears
    U2 – Joshua Tree
    The Beatles – Abbey Road
    The Eagles – Hotel California
    The Doors – Greatest Hits (is this cheating?)

  5. Nancy Willing says:

    I sure hope we are all stranded together!
    I can haz more music?

  6. Frieda Berryhill says:

    Now I really feel ooooooold, with me it’s Benny Goodman, Glen Miller and Harry James……….but I did finally take to the Beatles.
    I call that progress………

  7. Stella Bluez says:

    OH…..Freida,

    don’t feel oooold music is magical & whatever thrills you is RIGHT for you….

    I love all music!!!

  8. Frieda Berryhill says:

    Thanks Stella ! My son took me to a Grateful Dead concert some years back . He was the hero of that evening with people saying….I wish I could get my mom to come !……. They attention I got was better the concert. …And I learned a lot about our young people

  9. Frieda Berryhill says:

    Thanks Stella ! My son took me to a Grateful Dead concert some years back . He was the hero of that evening with people saying….I wish I could get my mom to come !……. The attention I got was better the concert. …And I learned a lot about our young people

  10. Frieda Berryhill says:

    Thanks Stella ! My son took me to a Grateful Dead concert some years back . He was the hero of that evening with people saying….I wish I could get my mom to come !……. The attention I got was better then the concert. …And I learned a lot about our young people

  11. jason330 says:

    Born to Run

    I don’t need five.

  12. cassandra_m says:

    London Calling — The Clash
    Complete Hot Fives and Sevens* — Louis Armstrong
    What’s Going On — Marvin Gaye
    Late String Quartets* (Takacs Quartet version) — Beethoven
    Ella Wishes You A Swinging Christmas — Ella Fitzgerald

    *multiple disks (it’s cheating, so what?)
    This list subject to change in 15 minutes.

  13. jason330 says:

    Maybe three come to think of it…

    Bossa Nova by John Pizzarelli and

    Squeeze – Singles 45 and Under

  14. Brian says:

    I’d need a few thernodies just in case my dog dies and a pipa to keep me playing music.

    But top five:

    12 Girls Band or the Evergreen Orchestra
    The Chieftans
    Kal HoNa Ho- From the Bollywood Classics
    Miles Davis-A Kind of Blue
    Venezuelan Alien- Raven

    Maybe a few album covers with picturs of Mai Charoenpura on them….and Mai 4.

  15. Pandora says:

    Wow! Really great picks! Let me add…

    Dire Straits, Making Movies
    Miles Davis (ditto Brian!)
    Any Elvis Costello
    Bob Marley, Legend
    Sublime

  16. jason330 says:

    OMG – how did I forget Making Movies?!

    A lovestruck Romeo sings a streetsuss serenade
    Laying everybody low with the love song that he made

    Finds a streetlight Steps out of the shade, says something like – you and me Babe, how ’bout it?

    Classic!

    …and My Aim is True. Now I’m over my limit.

  17. Brian says:

    how could i forget bob marley….scratch one of the others….

  18. Nancy Willing says:

    I am down with Dire Straights [Sultan of Swing], Beatles, Bob Marley, Pink Floyd, Warren Zevon and Miles Davis but I am gong to want some Velvet Underground, Yes, Animals, Kinks and early Elvis. Hank Williams, Golden Earring, Spirit, Donovan, Van Morrison, The Doors, Joanie Mitchell, Bonnie Raitt, Led Zep and the Rolling Stones.
    Now for the next two decades!!! Sex Pistols, Dead Kennedies, Metallica, Cobain and Vedder
    must go cut the grass………………….

  19. Nancy Willing says:

    Frieda, my dad only listened to the big bands. I remember him, in the rare moment that he stretched out on the couch, listening to the music of his youth. He danced to the big bands on piers off of the coast of Lake Erie in Ohio in the heyday.

  20. cassandra m says:

    This Year’s Model made my shortlist, as did More Songs About Buildings and Food. Aretha Franklin was also on the shortlist — Young, Gifted and Black or Spirit in the Dark maybe. I’d forgotten about Marley (that was the soundtrack to a summer I spent in Utah) and it is too hard to pick just one thing from Miles…..

  21. Damn, Cassandra…Costello and the Talking Heads. We must meet. You…me…Pandora…drinks? With Peter Gabriel providing the ambient noise, no less…

  22. Pandora says:

    Always up for drinks and good music. One of the best concerts I went to was Elvis Costello at the Tower Theater. His opening act? Squeeze!

  23. RickJ19958 says:

    Billy Bragg, Worker’s Playtime
    Bob Dylan, Biograph
    Bruce Springsteen, Nebraska
    The Smiths, Meat Is Murder
    The Cure, Disintegration

    If you had me pegged for any of these albums, give yourself a round of applause.

  24. RickJ19958 says:

    Oh, crap. Scratch the Cure and put on The Jayhawks – Tomorrow the Green Grass.

  25. Sagacious Steve says:

    The Band-‘The Band’
    Steely Dan-‘Countdown to Ecstasy’
    The Clash-‘London Calling’
    Tom Waits-‘Raindogs’
    Bruce Springsteen-‘The Wild, the Innocent & the E-Street Shuffle’

  26. Mrs. Hotviti says:

    rickj,

    I had you pegged for a Pet Shop Boys album or Frankie goes to hollywood

  27. El Somnambulo says:

    Los Lobos: “How Will the Wolf Survive”
    The Blasters: “Non-Fiction”
    Replacements: “Let It Be”
    Husker Du: “New Day Rising”
    Was (Not Was): “What Up, Dog?”

  28. Dominique says:

    Bruce – Born to Run or Greetings from Asbury Park
    DMB – Under the Table and Dreaming or Crash
    Dixie Chicks – Taking the Long Way
    Patty Griffin – Living With Ghosts
    Counting Crows – August and Everything After or Recovering the Satellites

  29. Dominique says:

    ooh, maybe Natalie Merchant’s Tigerlily or 10,000 Maniacs’ In My Tribe.

    This is harder than I thought it would be.

  30. I’ve got more than 1,000 CD’s, so this will definitely be tough. Gimme a few days…

  31. Pandora says:

    Love 10,000 Maniacs! OMG! Husker Du! Love them too! This is too hard! Gotta a soft spot for King Crimson and Brian Eno as well!

    Some great new stuff, too! Green Day, Outkast, Black Eyed Peas, Scissor Sisters, and, sigh, Nelly. Basically I love music!

  32. RickJ19958 says:

    Mrs. Hotviti –

    Naw, when I listen to flaming Euro-pop I go all out. Give me Erasure. Or better yet, Yaz – back when Vince Clarke had some edge to him. Plus, with Yaz you get Alison Moyet, so it’s win/win.

    What?

  33. Pandora says:

    Yaz! Upstairs at Eric’s! What a fun album! Yes, album!

    I can’t stop posting. Great memories!

  34. Dominique says:

    Maybe some Usher and some Eminem, too. Of course, Usher would be better if he was in video format.

  35. liberalgeek says:

    OK, scratch the Eagles. The Cowboy Junkies – The Trinity Session.

    And Matthews, don’t go stealing my women! 🙂

  36. Pandora says:

    Usher? YEAH!

  37. Von Cracker says:

    The Moderation Monster has eaten my list!

  38. chris o says:

    1) The White Album
    2) pink floyd — animals
    3) black sabbath — paranoid
    4) elton john — tumbleweed connection
    5) radiohead — ok computer

  39. jason330 says:

    RickJ,

    Billy Bragg, Worker’s Playtime.

    Best. Album. Ever.

    But what are you doing listening to it? That is lefty music.

  40. liberalgeek says:

    All conservatives secretly want to be liberals. Their parents would disapprove, however.

  41. RickJ19958 says:

    I would love it if you hippies would sit around making albums like Worker’s Playtime and let us run the state, Jason. Besides, Worker’s Playtime isn’t lefty music. Talking With the Taxman About Poetry is.

    Ah, Billy Bragg. Now there’s a Socialist for you. Not like that Dana Garrett.

  42. liberalgeek says:

    now we’re gonna get letters…

  43. Nancy Willing says:

    While I was doing chores I thought Traffic and Crosby Stills Nash and Young and more Young. Cat Stevens and the San Fran sound of Janis and Jefferson Airplane.
    Green Day, Bad Religion, OffSpring .
    Cracker. Black Sabbath, of course Husker Du and Counting Crows first album.
    *sigh* and all of the one hit wonders that we listened to in the 60’s with the transister to the ear keyed to WAMS before MMR took it all to another level.
    Tom Petty, the Band sheeeeet how to stop. And I havent’ even gone over to the boxes to take a look the darn collection.

  44. liberalgeek says:

    OK, Nance, pick 5 already…

  45. RAY K> says:

    No CD`s, what are you going to do for power? Just give me pictures of our gov. in a bathing suite. I won`t want to be rescued!

  46. Elton John-Caribou
    Bruce Springsteen-Born to Run
    Pink Floyd-The Wall
    Maynard Ferguson-MF Horn I&II
    Fleetwood Mac-The Chain

  47. Nancy Willing says:

    OK, Nance, pick 5 already…
    *
    my albums have been ib storage for toooooo long

  48. Sagacious Steve says:

    Dunno, Rick J. ‘Waiting for the Great Leap Forward’ is lefty-anthemic enough for me.

    Great pick, though…

  49. Dana says:

    Wouldn’t matter what I chose if there weren’t any electricity to play them!

  50. RickJ19958 says:

    Granted, Sagacious Steve, but the rest of that album (with the possible exception of “Tender Comrade”, which carries a little politics) is some of the most personal, gut-wrenching stuff ever. And beautiful.

  51. Another Mike says:

    I’m going to cheat and include one greatest hits album on my list.

    Billy Joel — 12 Gardens
    Counting Crows — Recovering the Satellites
    The Beatles — White Album
    Live — Throwing Copper
    Metallica — Black Album

  52. cassandra m says:

    Very nice, LG — The Cowboy Junkies are way better than the Eagles!

    Lots of great choices here! Husker Du is a real flashback and I wish I had put something of theirs on my Ipod today.

    For all of you Billy Bragg fans — have you listened to the Mermaid Avenue disks with Billy Bragg and Wilco putting music to previously unheard Woody Guthrie lyrics? Fantastic, esp. the first one.

  53. RickJ19958 says:

    cassandra,

    Both albums were great. And what a perfect choice of musicians to perform it. While they come from different worlds, Bragg is the perfect inheritor of the Guthrie legacy (sorry, Arlo!).

  54. Sagacious Steve says:

    Surprised that this has semi-turned into a Billy Bragg thread. Whodathunkit? Gotta say that I’m torn between ‘Worker’s Playtime’ and ‘Don’t Try This at Home’ as my fave BB ever. Glad that I’ve got both, and you should too.

  55. jason330 says:

    Worker’s Playtime is just song after song of great poetry set to great music with big pop hooks.

    I’d put it close to Born to Run as a very nearly perfect album.

  56. G Rex says:

    Clash – London Calling
    Metallica – Master of Puppets
    Miles Davis – Bitches Brew
    Beastie Boys – Licensed to Ill
    Dire Straits – Alchemy (okay, that’s kind of a cheat, but I couldn’t pick between the first album and Love over Gold.)

  57. Andy says:

    Anything by the tempatations
    Some BB King
    A little bit of Chuck Berry
    Clapton’s Unplugged
    AC DC Black in Black
    the first 3 would be some sort of greatest hits albums but so what

  58. RSmitty says:

    My luck, I’d be stranded there with Jason, so here is how I’d dole up the choices:

    ME:
    Jeff BuckleyGrace
    YesYessongs (I know, sort of cheating being a concert compilation)
    Peter GabrielHit (I’m cheating again)
    REM – Anything from Out Of Time and earlier, although Eponymous is a good compilation of their I.R.S. days
    White ZombieSupersexy Swingin’ Sounds – very possibly one of the better remixed/compilations I have ever owned…ever.

    Stopping at five sucks.

    As for Jason’s library on this island: the entire ABBA catalogue. That’s what you get for getting us stuck, you bastard!

  59. Dominique says:

    RSmitty –

    Jeff Buckley’s version of Hallelujah on that album (CD?) is goosebump-worthy. Good call.

  60. Fuck it. I’m doing 10. Flame me all you want for breaking the rules.

    Criteria: Albums in which I never have to press the “skip” button. Out of about 1,000 CDs, my guess is less than 50 meet this criteria.

    Richard Thompson, “Mock Tudor”
    Me’Shell NdeGeocello, “Bitter”
    Joe Henry, “Fuse”
    The Beatles, “Abbey Road”
    Bjork, “Homogenic”
    David Byrne, “Feelings”
    Emmylou Harris, “Red Dirt Girl”
    Talking Heads, “Remain in Light”
    Leonard Cohen, “The Future”
    Marilyn Manson, “Mechanical Animals”

    Albums missing include some U2, Prince, Travis, Tom Waits, Bruce Springsteen, Peter Gabriel, Morrissey, The Smiths, Warren Zevon, White Stripes, Wilco, Ween, Aimee Mann, Stevie Wonder, Michael Jackson (don’t laugh), Ryan Adams.

    Ok, I’m rambling. Either way, great thread!

  61. RickJ19958 says:

    Aw, crap. I just heard “Panic Beach”, from Maria McKee’s 1989 self-titled debut. Cross off Nebraska.

  62. jason330 says:

    Mike –

    It is your choice, but Ten CDs means that you don’t get the medical kit or the fishing hooks.

  63. RickJ19958 says:

    Mike –

    It is your choice, but Ten CDs means that you don’t get the medical kit or the fishing hooks.

    Or the stereo. Or the inflatable raft.

  64. RSmitty says:

    …but Jason’s ABBA collection probably gets to make the trip. Bastard.

  65. RSmitty says:

    …then again, if Jason’s collection gets to be lost at sea with him, then push the bastard overboard…him and his ABBA.

  66. Sagacious Steve says:

    From Robert Christgau’s review of ABBA’s Greatest Hits, Vol. 2:

    “We have met the enemy, and they are them.”

  67. Dominique says:

    ABBA Gold is, hands down, the best cleaning CD ever. Ever.

    Mike – that’s a very eclectic list. It’s not every day you see a list that includes Emmylou Harris and Marilyn Manson. Oh, and I would choose Tom Waits’ Closing Time if the criteria is being able to listen without skipping.

  68. cassandra m says:

    Joe Henry! Mike, that is a drink-worthy list, but since you have 10, I think that means you are buying….

  69. RickJ19958 says:

    ABBA Gold is, hands down, the best cleaning CD ever. Ever.

    If, by “cleaning CD”, you mean “mildly abrasive” then I agree. Abba is sorority music. “Hey girls! Take a chance on me!”

  70. Dominique says:

    I mean if you have to clean your house, pop in the CD. It’ll be done in half the time.