A brief word…
I’ve been to Munich twice and for the Oktoberfest both times. The second trip was a group adventure. Ten of us rented apartments in Munich and in Amsterdam for 19 days total.
While in Munich a small group decided to tour the Dachau memorial. I was in the group that passed on this one. It was unfortunate that I was in an odd head-space, but I knew I wouldn’t be able to handle it. I was in beer drinking mode. (A few years later I braved the Anne Frank House tour on another trip the Netherlands. It’s very heavy emotionally.)
The tour group returned disturbed. They described the grounds and the memorial. It was as grim as you can imagine.
While we were walking out to dinner a very close friend of mine pulled me aside. He said, “you know what the most awful part was? It’s in a neighborhood with shops and homes just past the fence and hedgerow.”
He asked the tour guide when the adjacent homes we’re built. Early 19th century.
Those people lived there while 180,000 political prisoners were housed there. While they ate their lunches over 30,000 human beings were incinerated just behind the trees. How often was it downwind?
People will turn a blind eye. They’re convinced it is for national security. They’re convinced the prisoners are dangerous enemies of the state. They were convinced that removing these people from society would allow the economy to recover, private enterprise thrive and the country to achieve greatness.
Well, I’m not ignoring it. Police menacing and murdering black and brown people in the street. Jailing families running for their lives in concentration camps after kidnapping their children. And saying it’s “the law”.
You want to convince me that supporting Carper, who voted to give the President the authority to constitute ICE? Who voted to confirm Secretary of Homeland Security Nielsen? And why, because the “majority” of the people (whoever they are) don’t care about the issue or think it’s cool?
No.
If you believe in core values we have an option. There are assuredly “other” people who share them. This, and issues like this, are about as clear cut as it comes. If you want to come play games here that’s fine. I don’t get mad or asks for blocks or bans. I haven’t the means or the desire. But I get intensely mean and extremely vulgar. If you think you’re tricky, you aren’t.
These aren’t radical things.
Single Payer Medicare for All.
$15 minimum wage.
Security in housing and in retirement.So, this is where I’m at. Have at it. But if you expect hand-holding or civil treatment this may not be the place for you right now. We have real work to do.
RE Vanella
Editors Note: Saint Simonian Olinde Rodrigues, in his essay “L’artiste, le savant et l’industriel” (1825) coined the term “avant-garde” to mean a person that pushes the boundaries of what is accepted as the norm or the status quo, particualrly in the pursuit of radical social reforms.
What some think of radical social reforms today will be tomorrow’s self-evident facts of life. If REV is the avant-garde today, it is only because he got to where we are all going first.
I’ve been, and it is every bit as taxing as you can imagine. When Patton’s army liberated Dachau, he forced the townspeople to tour the camp and to help clean up the bodies so that they would know what it looked like first hand. Many of the soldiers involved in the liberation were physically ill at the sight of what they encountered.
The social science research since overwhelmingly confirms that it could happen here, that people will conform, that obedience to authority is an American trait as much as a German one, that there is such a thing as an authoritarian personality, that those people will be the first to be the true believes, but that others will stay silent or go along with the group. I always hesitate about being alarmist, but kids in cages, for me, crossed a moral line. The “president” calling for an end to Due Process crossed a line. So many other things…so sound the alarm, do it loudly, and we need to fight like hell, with anyone willing to stand up together to fight, to save ourselves from the brink.
Great comment Mike. We tend to think that the social/political muscles that we’ll need to resist fascism will simply be there when we need them. That’s not how muscles work.
To oppose fascism we have to educate what the term means. The alt right on purpose or through ignorance believe socialism is communism. When you use the word fascism as a description your called the radical left. Trump crosses the line everyday proving he is a true fascist. Trashing Canada, Mexico, NATO, UN, sending a trash letter to our european allies to pony up more money or else, he works everyday on behalf of Russia. How do we get the “poorly educated, historical inept supporters to stop the hating?
Thanks for reading and commenting, Mike.