Spotlight Delaware’s Jake Owens On The Mugshot Bill

What do you think?:

Well-intentioned law needs work
In the past two months, Delaware has been at the forefront of public debate around the intersection of government transparency, the public’s right to information, public safety and individual privacy.

That debate centers around House Bill 59, which was signed into law in October and has limited the police’s ability to release defendants’ names and mugshots. Following an advisory opinion by the Attorney General, virtually all identification of criminal defendants by police departments has ended – a step that makes Delaware a first again.

The intent of HB 59 – sometimes referred to as the “Mugshots Bill” – was fair, but its execution requires fine tuning. 

Unfortunately, the police blotter of yore has become a digitized scarlet letter for even the most innocuous offender in 2026. In my 16 years in the media industry, I’ve received more complaints from long-rehabilitated offenders over their lingering internet footprint than any other issue.

When I led newspapers in Maryland, a young man once called me every month for a year to politely request we remove an article detailing his public drug possession arrest. He’d explain that he got the court system to expunge the crime in its system – allowing him to receive a clean background check – but the one hang up in every job interview was our story, which topped Google search results for his name.

I would politely explain that our policy was not to unpublish accurate information, because doing so would create a slippery slope that would be untenable. He understood and would try again. I anguished over that policy for years.

Today, most legacy newspapers have limited or eliminated their use of mugshots, even before HB 59 was signed into law. But now social media accounts – sometimes incentivized by monetization programs – collect and publish such releases daily for an incensed internet mob.

How can we expect the truly repentant to better themselves and succeed if we as a society are unwilling to allow them to do so? Where should the press – and burgeoning social media channels – draw a line as to their part to that shared social responsibility?

My experience supports the intent of HB 59, but, as I sit today, I also believe it was a rushed piece of legislation that could have been improved with more time. Few bills benefit from being passed in the twilight hours of a final legislative day, as HB 59 was. It’s already clear that there were misunderstandings on the bill’s application.

In particular, I believe HB 59’s two-pronged test for felony crimes is ill-conceived. The bill requires that an identifiable person has been both charged with a felony and the release of their information is necessary to protect the public’s safety. Because of that tiny word “and,” the bill essentially prevents the release of information about any individual charged with a felony, unless they’re actively on the lam.

But there are felony scenarios – such as murder, sexual abuse and fraud – in which the identification of the accused, even after being arrested, could be critically important to victims in our community. The current advice from the Delaware Department of Justice cautions police against disclosing identities in most scenarios.

It’s incumbent upon our government to balance public safety with individual rights to privacy, and good legislation can help do that. Unfortunately, HB 59 hasn’t quite achieved that and, instead, has limited the public’s access to information that could help victims obtain justice.

Thanks for reading,
Jacob Owens

Editor in Chief, Spotlight Delaware

jowens@spotlightdelaware.org

 

1 Comment

  1. My concern is that, as currently interpreted by the police, they can effectively arrest someone in secret. Surely that’s an unintended consequence.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *