Tom Corbett Hates Free Speech
Tom Corbett won a convincing victory on Tuesday in the Republican primary for governor of Pennsylvania. Corbett is the state’s Attorney General. He is known for aggressive prosecution of state officials (from both parties) and for joining the lawsuit against health care reform. He’s making waves again, this time by trying to subpoena Twitter to find the identity of some critics.
The subpoena orders Twitter to provide “any and all subscriber information” of the person(s) behind two accounts – @bfbarbie and @CasaBlancaPA – who have been anonymously criticizing the man on the popular micro-sharing service.
…
The account @CasaBlancaPA, whose owner is identified as ‘Signor Ferrari’ (a criminal in the film Casablanca, played by Sydney Greenstreet) on Twitter, links to this blog in the bio section. The blog, hosted on Google’s Blogger service, is dedicated to “exposing the hypocrisy of Tom Corbett” according to its subtitle.
Some choice tweets that may have gotten the @CasaBlancaPA account owner in trouble:
– “Is it wrong to mix campaign work with taxpayer business? Apparently not when Tom Corbett does it bonusgate #pagovrace” (tweet, blog post)
– “Corbett erupts at campaign event; security tries to eject questioner #bonusgate #pagovrace” (tweet, blog post)
– “Quiz! Who sputters with indignation over failure to recuse from cases involving contributors? #bonusgate #pagovrace” (tweet, blog post)
Polls have shown that Pennsylvanians have not paid much attention to the governor’s race. Could this be why Corbett is doing this? If so, he picked a bad way to introduce himself to voters. He looks thin-skinned and petty.
Tags: PA-Gov, Tom Corbett, Twitter
I know a bit about libel and slander, and those three examples are not even close, particularly the last two. The only thing close to defaming the character of Corbett, if he has any, is the one accusing him of mixing campaign work with regular work. He’s a public figure, so he would have to prove that the allegation is true, caused him harm and was done with actual malice. This is not an easy threshold. There’s a reason why so many public figures spout off about suing someone for libel and nothing ever coming of it.
Someone ought to ask this AG if this effort is a good use of taxpayer funds. Using your political office to *out* critics is just more GOP bullying.
As I said in yesterday’s open thread, he’s channeling Joe McCarthy.